Consignment Shops Nyc That Buy Clothes May 2026

: Items should be clean and in good repair. Many shops, including Crossroads Trading , value trendiness and condition above brand name alone.

: While Buffalo Exchange and Crossroads typically allow walk-ins, some high-end shops or local favorites like Consignment on Atlantic may require appointments. Payout Comparison Cash Payout (% of Retail) Trade/Credit Payout (% of Retail) Beacon's Closet Crossroads Trading Buffalo Exchange 2nd STREET Varies (often ~30%) Mr Goods Buy & Sell consignment shops nyc that buy clothes

One of the most popular options in the city, with locations in Greenpoint , Park Slope, Bushwick , and Manhattan . They are recognized for providing some of the highest rates, offering or 55% in store credit of their estimated retail price. Crossroads Trading : Items should be clean and in good repair

Specializes in trendy and high-quality clothing. They offer or 50% in trade value immediately. For high-end luxury items, they may also offer a traditional consignment path with payouts reaching up to 70%. Buffalo Exchange Used clothing store ClosedBrooklyn, NY Payout Comparison Cash Payout (% of Retail) Trade/Credit

Located in Lower Manhattan, this shop specializes in designer clothing, luxury handbags, and high-end sneakers. Reviewers often highlight their fast "cash in hand" process, sometimes completing transactions in under 30 minutes. 2nd STREET